TL;DR: Understanding Confirm Shaming
- Dark pattern confirm shaming makes you feel bad for not choosing the option a website prefers. It presents the desired choice positively and the alternative negatively, often using guilt. This tactic particularly affects people with anxiety, as it can make leaving a service feel risky.
- Recognizing this manipulation is the first step to resisting its psychological pressure. In today’s digital world, websites and apps constantly ask us to make choices. Most of these decisions are small.
- However, some online interfaces use manipulative techniques, known as dark patterns, to guide you towards choices you might not otherwise make. One particularly sneaky tactic is the dark pattern confirm shaming.
What Exactly is Dark Pattern Confirm Shaming?
The dark pattern confirm shaming is a user interface design choice that aims to make you hesitate or feel guilty about declining an offer or a particular option. It works by framing the choice the business wants you to make in a positive light. Conversely, it portrays the alternative – the option the business doesn’t want you to select – in a negative or guilt-inducing way.
Imagine you’re trying to opt out of a newsletter. Instead of a simple “No, thanks,” the button might say, “No, I don’t want to receive useful tips and discounts.” This phrasing is a classic example of the dark pattern confirm shaming. It subtly questions your decision, making you feel like you might be missing out or making a poor choice.
Spotting Confirm Shaming: Real-World Examples
Many companies employ these tactics. A well-known example can be seen on e-commerce sites like Amazon. When you proceed to checkout, you might be offered their Prime service. The option to sign up for Prime is often presented in a bright, appealing box, highlighting benefits like “FREE unlimited fast delivery.”
However, if you choose not to sign up, the alternative option might be a muted, grey button. The text could say something like, “No thanks, I don’t want unlimited fast delivery.” This use of the dark pattern confirm shaming is designed to make you second-guess your decision. It subconsciously suggests that saying no is an inherently bad or less savvy choice.
Here is an article that calls out 40 examples of confirm shaming showcasing various examples from across the web.
The Harmful Impact of Confirm Shaming
While it might seem like a minor annoyance, the dark pattern confirm shaming can have a significant negative impact, especially on certain groups of people.
- Exploiting Vulnerabilities: Individuals living with social anxiety, panic disorders, or PTSD can be particularly susceptible. These conditions often involve a heightened fear of making wrong decisions or being judged.
- Inducing Negative Feelings: The language used in confirm shaming is designed to make users feel embarrassed, humiliated, or foolish for not selecting the preferred option.
- Creating Decision Anxiety: For someone prone to anxiety, the guilt trip embedded in confirm shaming can make it much harder to decline a service or offer, even if it isn’t right for them. They might fear that something negative will happen as a consequence of their choice.
- Eroding Trust: Over time, encountering such manipulative tactics erodes user trust in a brand or service. People begin to feel that their needs are not being respected.
- Impeding Fair Access: For individuals whose access needs are being used against them, this practice is particularly unfair. They may feel pressured into choices that aren’t in their best interest simply to avoid a feeling of shame.
The core issue with the dark pattern confirm shaming is its attempt to manipulate your emotions to achieve a business goal. It steers you away from making a clear, unbiassed decision.
Why Do Companies Use It?
The primary reason companies use tactics like confirm shaming is to increase conversion rates for their preferred options – be it signing up for a subscription, agreeing to marketing emails, or purchasing a premium service. They bank on the idea that a little psychological nudge, or even a feeling of guilt, will be enough to sway your decision.
How to Protect Yourself from Dark Pattern Confirm Shaming
Awareness is the first and most crucial step in countering the effects of the dark pattern confirm shaming.
- Recognize the Tactic: When you see options phrased to make you feel bad for saying “no,” identify it as confirm shaming.
- Pause Before Clicking: Take a moment to consider if the “shameful” alternative is actually bad for you, or if it’s just being framed that way.
- Focus on Your Needs: Make your decision based on what you genuinely want or need, not on the emotionally loaded language presented.
- Remember Your Rights: You have the right to decline offers without feeling guilty.
By understanding how the dark pattern confirm shaming works, you can become more resilient to its influence. Businesses should aim to provide clear, neutral choices, respecting user autonomy rather than resorting to emotional manipulation to drive engagement.
Do you need assistance with website accessibility? Want to check your website is as compliant as it can be? Get in touch with us and we will help you identify how to improve your website’s accessibility.